< BACK TO POSTS

By Todd Kuhlmann, Founder of TheAnalyst® PRO

Two-thirds of commercial real estate pros now use AI every week. Only 5% trust it enough to inform a real deal decision.

66%
use AI weekly or daily
53%
keep AI out of final decisions entirely
5%
trust AI to inform a real deal decision

Source: First American Data & Analytics and DealGround, CRE Industry Pulse Check (2026)

That's the headline finding of the CRE Industry Pulse Check, a 2026 survey of 255 brokers, lenders, developers and asset managers by First American Data & Analytics and DealGround. 66% use AI weekly or daily. 53% use it for support only and keep it out of final decisions entirely.

In other words, 95% of the industry won't let AI make the call.

66% of CRE pros use AI weekly, but only 5% trust it to inform a real deal decision
AI is everywhere in commercial real estate. Trust for deal decisions is not.

That isn't fear of technology. These are the same people using AI every day to summarize leases, draft marketing copy and pull research. They've just drawn a clear line: AI helps with the paperwork. The decision on price, value and risk stays with a professional who can show the work.

If you're a broker writing a BOV, an investor sizing up a 12-unit, or a lender reviewing a loan request, that line matters to you too. Here's why the 95% drew it, and how to stay on the right side of it without slowing down.

Five Reasons the 95% Keep AI Out of the Decision

1. You Still Have to Check Every Number

In Dealpath's 2026 State of AI in CRE Investing survey of institutional investment pros, published in PwC and ULI's Emerging Trends in Real Estate, 94% check AI outputs most of the time or always. Dealpath calls this the “verification tax.”

The tax is real. 41% said work involving AI now takes longer than doing the analysis manually. In lending, 51% said AI slows them down, because loan documents demand line-by-line precision.

One transposed expense line on a T-12 flows straight into NOI. At a 7% cap rate, a small error becomes a big one:

$7,000 NOI error ÷ 7% cap rate = $100,000 swing in value

2. The Data Behind the Deal Is Messy

AI is only as good as what it reads, and CRE data lives in scanned leases, one-off spreadsheets, rent rolls and email threads. In the same Dealpath survey, 90% said data quality or fragmentation limits AI's impact. When AI falls short, incomplete or inconsistent data is the most-cited cause (43%), ahead of outright hallucinations (36%).

3. AI Is Weakest Exactly Where the Money Is

Trust drops the closer AI gets to a valuation:

Task Institutional pros who highly trust AI
Summarize diligence documents 55%
Recommend comps 36%
Score and rank deals 35%

Underwriting has the lowest AI adoption of any stage, at 48%.

The math itself is part of the problem. In Fin-RATE, a 2026 benchmark built from real SEC filings, the best model tested topped out at 43–44% accuracy on analyst-style tasks. A lending benchmark from JurisTech found models producing calculations from inputs they had made up.

A DCF should give you the same answer every time you run the same inputs. A chatbot doesn't promise that.

4. Your Name Is on the Number

No client, partner or credit committee will accept “the AI got it wrong” as an explanation. The survey authors put it plainly:

“Many CRE workflows depend on explainability, provenance and defensible outputs.” — First American Data & Analytics and DealGround, via Connect CRE

The standard-setters agree. In April 2026 the Appraisal Standards Board adopted Advisory Opinion 41, which makes clear the appraiser, not the tool, is responsible for credible results. RICS made its responsible-AI standard mandatory for members worldwide in March 2026, including professional oversight of AI outputs.

These rules govern appraisers and surveyors, but the message applies to anyone who puts a value in front of a client: you own the number, so you need to be able to show how you got it.

5. Deal Data Is Confidential

Rent rolls, operating statements and bid strategy are covered by NDAs and client trust. Bisnow reports that data privacy and security concerns are among the reasons CRE pros hold back from AI. Meanwhile, 71% of the institutional pros Dealpath surveyed use general-purpose chatbots directly. Pasting a client's T-12 into a public AI tool is a risk most brokers haven't thought through.

Skip the Verification Tax Entirely

AI promised speed. For underwriting, the speed disappears once you check the work. In Dealpath's 2025 survey, 61% of institutional investors expected AI to deliver faster deals. A year later, only 35% named deal speed as one of AI's biggest wins, and just 19% said it led to more precise investment decisions.

Here's the simple comparison for a Main Street deal:

The AI Route
Paste in the rent roll and T-12, get a model back, then check every line, formula and assumption against the source documents. You still own any mistake you miss.
The TheAnalyst PRO Route
Enter the same numbers into a proven DCF engine and have a complete investment analysis in 5–10 minutes. Every assumption is visible. Every calculation is the same one that has run more than 100,000 analyses over 15+ years.
TheAnalyst PRO Returns at a Glance report comparing Cash on Cash, Return on Equity, OmniReturn and IRR by year
Nothing hidden: TheAnalyst PRO's Returns at a Glance report shows every return measure by year, with the formula behind each one. Click the image to enlarge.

When the checking takes longer than the analysis, the fastest path is the one you don't have to check.

Institutional Grade, Built for Main Street

The big firms in these surveys manage $500 million to more than $40 billion. They have analysts, data teams and investment committees to catch errors. The boutique broker, the private investor and the community lender usually don't. That makes a transparent, proven model more important on Main Street, not less.

That's the idea behind TheAnalyst PRO:

Institutional-Grade CRE Tools for Analysis, Marketing, and Deal Execution Powerful enough for the most demanding workflows. Simple enough to use every day.

  • Brokers: back your pricing and BOVs with an analysis your client can follow line by line, then turn it into professional offering materials and share it through the DealRoom.
  • Investors and syndicators: model cash flow, returns and partner splits with assumptions you set and can defend to your partners.
  • Lenders: review a deal on a transparent cash flow, not a summary you'd have to recreate to trust.
Property flyer shared with buyers through TheAnalyst PRO DealRoom
From analysis to marketing: offering materials shared with buyers through TheAnalyst PRO's branded DealRoom.

Work Like the 95%

You don't have to give up AI. Use it the way the top firms do:

  1. Let AI handle the paperwork. Summarize leases, draft property descriptions, organize your notes.
  2. Let a proven model make the numbers. Run the cash flow, returns and valuation in TheAnalyst PRO, where every assumption is visible.
  3. Let a professional make the call. Review the analysis, apply your local market knowledge, and put your name on a number you can defend.

AI for the paperwork. A transparent model for the decision. That's what institutional grade looks like.

Schedule a Demo of TheAnalyst PRO

Sources

This article is for educational purposes and summarizes publicly available industry research. It is not investment, legal, accounting, or tax advice.


Posted: 12-31-1969 7:00PM EST